Newspaper icon
The latest issue of Financial Standard now available as an e-newspaper
READ NOW

Investment

Clime IM fee payment, dividend delayed over audit issues

Clime Investment Management's $2.25 million performance fee from Clime Capital, the listed investment company it manages, has been held up after auditors could not verify the value of the fund's unlisted assets portfolio.

The delay puts a question mark over a payment that underpinned the fund manager's FY26 profit.

Clime IM reported a statutory net profit of $0.8 million for the year to June 30, after a $0.5 million profit in FY25 and a $3.8 million loss the year before. The result included $2.25 million in performance fees from Clime Capital in FY26, almost three times the company's statutory profit for the year.

Clime Investment Management was suspended from the ASX in October after it missed the September 30 deadline to lodge its audited annual report. The suspension was lifted on October 16 after it provided its FY26 annual report.

Clime IM chair Paul Lahiff told the company's annual general meeting (AGM) payment of the fee had been delayed because Clime Capital's FY26 accounts were issued with a "qualified audit opinion", where the auditor signs off on the accounts except for a specific area where it could not obtain enough evidence.

The board has also deferred a decision on its proposed fully franked final dividend of 0.5 cents a share until an independent valuation of $36.2 million in unlisted assets covered by the qualification is complete.

At Clime Capital's AGM the same day, chair John Abernethy said the qualification was disappointing.

"The qualification related, in particular, to the auditor being unable to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to verify the unit prices or values of certain unlisted investments," he said.

"The board takes this matter seriously and has been working with the manager to address the matters identified."

Abernethy said the manager was obtaining up-to-date valuations from third-party valuers that complied with ASIC guidelines announced in mid-June.

"This work is substantially complete and at this stage the values of the unlisted credit, property, and equity assets remain at values attributed as at 30 June," he said.

"Further, the board has commissioned an additional independent review. The engagement is intended to assess the value, security, and recoverability, of Clime Capital's private debt portfolio."

On the audit issues, Lahiff acknowledged the audit valuation concerns noting increased regulatory and audit focus on private market valuations has required additional independent evidence.

"Independent valuation work has been commissioned, reporting and oversight processes are being strengthened, and management continues to work with the relevant investment managers, independent valuers and auditors to complete the outstanding requirements," he said.

"It is important to distinguish between the timing and availability of sufficient audit evidence and a determination that an investment has suffered a loss.

"Nevertheless, shareholders are entitled to expect robust governance, appropriate documentation and reliable financial reporting."

Clime Capital shareholders also delivered the company a first strike, with 28% of votes cast against its remuneration report.

Abernethy stepped down as Clime IM chair in March after more than three decades on the board, including five years as chair, and was replaced by Lahiff as an independent chair. He remains a director and director of investments at Clime IM and continues to chair Clime Capital.

The governance questions come as Clime IM completes a restructure in which it sold its financial advice business and its separately managed accounts business.

"For many years, Clime operated across financial advice, managed funds, separately managed accounts, listed investment vehicles and investment management," Lahiff said.

"While these businesses offered opportunities, they also created operational complexity, overlapping costs, distribution dependencies and, in some cases, insufficient commercial scale."

Lahiff added these decisions were not simply about reducing costs.

"They were about ensuring that Clime concentrates its resources on the activities where it has a genuine competitive advantage," Lahiff said.

"Our direction is increasingly clear. Clime is an investment management business. We manage capital, not products. Our focus is on direct investment management relationships, bespoke mandates, asset consulting and investment opportunities across public and private markets."

Read more: Clime Capital,  Clime Investment Management,  AGM,  Paul Lahiff,  John Abernethy,  ASX