Performance test reforms open door to overlooked assetsBY KARREN VERGARA | WEDNESDAY, 18 NOV 2026 11:47AMThe superannuation performance test will make room for overlooked asset classes such as venture capital and agriculture in a bid to rein in benchmark hugging and force more platform products to be accountable for their investment performance and fees. Treasury will introduce a new, voluntary benchmark in new investments made by trustees capped at up to 5% of their portfolios as part of three major updates to the annual performance test. Unveiling more tweaks to the annual performance test this morning, Treasurer Jim Chalmers estimates loosening the benchmark framework will unlock up to $90 billion of investment in emerging assets such as startups, housing and energy. The rationale behind this, Chalmers told the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) Conference in Melbourne while announcing the updates, is to "reduce benchmark hugging with more active management and diversification." "The new benchmark uses a neutral definition for eligible assets focused on where existing benchmarking options fall short, and it will be based on independent advice from the Australian government actuary, and it will be administered by APRA," he said. Chalmers flagged the 5% cap is a starting point and is subject to future reviews. This includes setting it at a margin above CPI with different levels of growth and defensive assets. "We think there are several reasons why these changes will strengthen, not weaken, the performance test or interfere with your obligations to members," he said. The second reform will see the test expand to cover more products, impacting 1.4 million more members. This means roping in externally directed products, which are managed by third parties instead of trustees and are comparable to products already captured in the test. "This ensures the test is competitively neutral, so that products don't fall in or out of the test due to their holding structure, and we'll phase it in with results reported in 2027-28 for transparency before the full application of the test in 2028-29," he said. The method by which fees are benchmarked for platform products will also change, he said, as having more platform products within the performance test's scope will stabilise the fee benchmarks and provide a more reliable basis for comparison. The third piece of reform will see Treasury specify which indices will be used in APRA determinations to make changes quicker and easier, and to promote competition between index providers. "We're addressing concerns that the indices used in the test are too rigid and that they can be too costly to access," he said. "We're also establishing a regular cycle to review the test with a structured, transparent process run by Treasury every three to five years, and this will provide a predictable checkpoint to ensure the test adapts as the system evolves." The failure rate has dropped from 16% in the test's first year to currently 2%. Platform products continue to make up most failures. This year, one MySuper product and 11 trustee-directed products (TDPs) failed out of a pool of 547 superannuation products APRA assessed. Some barriers removed In response, ASFA chief executive Mary Delahunty said the reforms will preserve the performance test's role in ensuring funds consistently perform well, while addressing unintended consequences of its original design. "Some investments, including new infrastructure or Australian start-ups, are not well represented by the indices used in the test as it is now. These are the 'emerging assets' the new benchmark will unlock funds' ability to invest in," she said. "Every product subject to the test will continue to be held to an objective standard. What will change is that funds will have less reason to pass up sound long-term investments just because they are poorly matched to the existing set of benchmarks." Excluded from the updated test are single-sector products, separately managed accounts (SMAs) and "any additional product cohorts where the test cannot provide a meaningful product assessment supported by reliable data." Financial Services Council (FSC) chief executive Blake Briggs said consultation on these exclusions will be important to address concerns about applying the test to investment options used as building blocks within broader portfolios. "The platform choice context should be distinguished from MySuper products. Advisers and members who are more engaged with their superannuation, exercising active choice, use investment options as building blocks for a wider retirement strategy," he said. "This differs from MySuper products, for which the test was originally designed, which generally provide a complete diversified investment strategy." Investing in agriculture and natural capital will no longer be discouraged by the performance test. Rest chief investment officer Michael Clancy said the current test makes it difficult for funds to consider these asset classes, even when they could deliver strong, long-term, risk-adjusted returns and are in members' best financial interests. "These assets are not well represented by existing benchmarks and often have materially different risk and return characteristics," he said. "A new emerging assets category and benchmark is a practical and commonsense reform. It would give funds greater flexibility to assess investment opportunities on their merits, while maintaining clear standards and consequences for underperformance." Stockspot chief executive Chris Brycki said a diversified portfolio of venture capital or private equity investments should at least be able to avoid underperforming public equities by more than 5% over rolling 10-year periods. "That's already a generous allowance for investments that involve higher risk and less liquidity. If a fund can't clear that hurdle then it should rightly face questions about whether those investments are in members' best financial interests," he said. "Would members have been better off simply owning a low-cost index fund? The empirical evidence supporting index investing makes that a very fair question. Related News |
Editor's Choice
Generation Life unveils protection feature for LifeIncome
Hostplus, HESTA invest in Remedy Robotics
Betashares launches global AI ETF
ASIC case dismissed against former Freedom Insurance director
Products
Expert Feed
Featured Profile

Fiona Macgregor
TAL LIMITED






