Lifecycle not the answer: Rice WarnerBY BEN COLLINS | TUESDAY, 27 NOV 2012 12:00PMTwo of retirement savings' biggest problems could be made worse by lifecycle Funds, which only help the poor returns caused by volatility, said Rice Warner Actuaries. |
Editor's Choice
IFM raises Atlas Arteria's bid, urges shareholders to accept
IFM Investors has raised its bid for Atlas Arteria to its maximum consideration of $5.10 per security, calling it the best and final offer in the absence of a competitive offer.
ASIC secures record $300m penalty over 'egregious' CFD misconduct
The Federal Court has imposed record penalties totalling more than $300 million against collapsed contracts for difference (CFD) issuer Union Standard International Group and two of its former authorised representatives.
ASX to pay $23m, admits misrepresentation over CHESS replacement
ASX has admitted that it misled and exposed market participants to financial risk in an announcement related to the delivery of the CHESS replacement project in early 2022, despite realising the delay would occur as early as 21 December 2021.
ACCC approves Magellan, Barrenjoey merger
The ACCC has greenlit the merger between Magellan Financial Group and Barrenjoey Capital Partners.
Products
Featured Profile

Brian Redican
CHIEF ECONOMIST
NEW SOUTH WALES TREASURY CORPORATION
NEW SOUTH WALES TREASURY CORPORATION
What makes an economist an economist? TCorp chief economist Brian Redican reflects on over three decades of navigating Australia's economic cycles. Riddhima Talwani writes.







A growing chorus recognise that the industry can and should do better than placing two MySuper members, one aged 18 who is likely to retire with a $1M and one age 65 years retiring on the Age Pension in the same asset allocation. Funds that have moved to Lifecycle or Target Date funds have been fighting with one hand tied because they simply reduce risk and return using one factor - Age. This results in both lower volatility as retirement approaches but at the high cost of lower retirement balances on average.
Fortunately the MySuper Lifecycle legislation allows for the use of more factors than age -one of these may well be projected retirement lifestyle/balance. Using multiple factors enables two 18 year olds, one expected to retire on a million and the other on the pension to be invested in different asset allocations and two 65 year olds to also be invested appropriately. Using this approach higher retirement balances for members and hence higher FUM for trustees on average can be achieved compared to the Default Option, while aligning member's asset allocation with their age and retirement prospects. Rice Warner should be widely congratulated on displaying this effect in the articles graph.
The 'simplest' approach mentioned in the article - using two portfolio's (cash and growth) is however unnecessary as a funds existing (choice) investment options (i.e. cash, conservative, aggressive, equities) are already in place. Trustee Tailored Super (www.trusteetailored.com) is an automated patented method for achieving this improved risk return outcome - not a Default Option not a Age Base Lifecycle Option but a new approach that uses the information already held by trustees in their own member databases.