Treasury responds to ABA derision over bank levy

Secretary to the Treasury has shot down claims from the Australian Bankers' Association that the proposed bank levy disregards Government best practice guidelines.

In a submission to Treasury lodged on Monday, ABA chief executive Anna Bligh claimed the lack of a regulatory impact statement is in direct opposition to the Government's own guide to regulation, stating: "The Government has failed to meet its own criteria around transparency and accountability in decisions, evidence-based policy development, and effective administration of regulation."

Responding to Bligh, Secretary to the Treasury John Fraser said a regulatory impact statement would be made available when the draft legislation is tabled, citing the inclusion of the levy in the Federal Budget followed thorough development as part of normal budget processes.

"Through those processes, careful consideration was given to the design of the levy, the costings and to its effect on the economy as well as the financial sector," Fraser wrote.

"As is usual practice we will be providing further relevant information including a regulatory impact statement canvassing the broader economic impacts, compliance issues and revenue estimates as part of the explanatory material accompanying the draft legislation when it is introduced into Parliament."

Bligh said a lack of quality consultation on the shaping of the levy could result in a poorly-designed tax impacting the finances of both the nation and everyday Australians.

"Further Treasury analysis is imperative, including on the modelling of the economic impacts of the tax, and banks should be given at least four weeks to respond to the Treasury analysis, the draft legislation and explanatory memorandum," Bligh said.

"A longer consultation period, including engagement between banks and all affected regulators, will help to avoid unintended consequences on the economy and financial system."

In response, Fraser pointed to Budget papers outlining revenue and expenditure decisions.

Fraser assured the ABA that, given the tight deadline imposed, his department is working with the Office of Parliamentary Counsel to prepare draft legislation as promptly as possible for the major banks to comment on.

NAB also released its submission to Treasury this week, staunchly opposing the levy.

"NAB believes the levy is poor policy and, accordingly, does not support it. The levy is not just on banks, it is a tax on every Australian who benefits from, and is part of, the banking industry. This includes NAB's 10 million customers, 570,000 direct NAB shareholders, those who own NAB shares through their superannuation, our 1700 suppliers and NAB's 34,000 employees. The levy cannot be absorbed; it will be borne by these people. It is not possible to increase taxes by this magnitude without it impacting people," the submission reads.

NAB stated its most obvious areas of concern are the calculation burden of the levy and the application of a clear disadvantage against global competitors in wholesale and institutional banking.

"NAB also expects that given the significance of the change and time allowed for consideration, there will be other consequences we have not currently identified," the submission stated.

Read more: TreasuryNABABAParliamentAnna BlighFederal Budget
Editor's Choice
About three-quarters of Australian institutional investors are incorporating environmental, social and governance factors in investment decisions.
Businesses looking to integrate enhanced technological capability must consider its future impacts, or else risk creating a greater trust deficit in the financial services industry.
A comprehensive review of Praemium chief executive Michael Ohanessian's termination and subsequent reinstatement determined the previous board acted inappropriately and unreasonably.
Advisers will soon have access to Challenger's deferred lifetime annuities through Colonial First State platforms.
Brought to you by
27 APR 2017
Smart beta strategies have come of age. I remember them being discussed several years ago with either cynicism or amusement among the institutional circles. Not many took 'smart beta' seriously. The tone ...
Get it Daily
Keep up to date, don't be the last to know! Get the Financial Standard Daily Newsletter.
Pocket investment guides featuring adviser case studies and a glossary.
Investing trends and strategies from the industry’s thought leaders.
Putting the spotlight on investment products that matter.
Expert Feed
Michelle Baltazar
A case for digital activism
The time is ripe for financial advisers to embrace their role as digital activists - fiduciaries who are early adopters of finance ...
Emma Rapaport
Smashed on university fees, smashed on retirement
Since Scott Morrison's pre-budget announcement that debt would be reclassified as 'good' or 'bad', the government spending spree has ...
Christopher Page
The next generation
On March 20, David Rockefeller - former Chase Manhattan chair and last of Standard Oil founder John D. Rockefeller's grandchildren ...
Michelle Baltazar
Hitting the mark
Ten years from now, every financial adviser in the country will be offering their client a managed account solution. It may happen ...
Featured Profile
Professional Subscription for $295
(inc GST) for 1 year.
FS Advice
The Australian Journal of Financial Planning.
Get the free iPad app
Download the Financial Standard iPad app for FREE.
Link to something ieIV9wp0