Banks must overhaul product-based incentives

Retail banking practices don't carry "significant systemic risks" that deliver poor customer outcomes, an independent review has found.

Some current practices however, are promoting unacceptable behaviours inconsistent with good customer outcomes and should be changed urgently. These are the latest findings as part of the Sedgwick Review, and form an extensive investigation between staff remuneration and products sold to retail and small business customers.

The report highlighted the importance of rewarding retail bank staff, in particular mortgage brokers and sellers, to no longer receive incentives based directly or solely on sales performance.

Personal incentive payments should not be dominated by sales, rather assessed on an individual's contribution across a range of measures, said former Australian Public Service Commissioner Stephen Sedgwick. He was appointed by the Australian Bankers' Association to lead the independent review of product sales commissions and product-based payments in retail banking.

Sedgwick said his proposed 21 recommendations promise to address the "trust deficit" in the banking industry and "signal a sharp break with the past."

"Changing remuneration alone is not enough. Each bank should address the issues holistically. This means many banks should also revise their target setting, performance management, leader development and, most importantly, culture; and ensure they are aligned with the ethical, customer - centric philosophy that underpins my recommendations," Sedgewick said.

National Australia Bank said it is committed to implementing the final recommendations.

NAB chief customer officer, consumer banking and wealth Andrew Hagger said: "These recommendations are a significant step for the industry and will require focus, discipline and strong leadership to implement them."

"We want our customers to be confident that every time they deal with their bank, they are receiving products and services that best suit their needs and we want to ensure bankers continue to be rewarded for doing the right thing," he said.

As an example, NAB moved away from performance-based, fixed pay increases for customer service and support staff; they instead will receive a standard pay rise of 3% per year under an enterprise agreement.

With respect to third parties such as mortgage brokers and aggregators, NAB said it does not pay volume-based incentives on residential mortgages to mortgage brokers, and agreed with the recommendations that any changes to such remuneration structures should be "viable" and "competitive."

ANZ also welcomed the findings and confirmed its commitment to implementing its recommendations, including working with both the broker industry and relevant regulators.

ANZ group executive Australia Fred Ohlsson said: "This review is an important step for the industry to continue to restore community trust and we are committed to implementing these recommendations as quickly as possible."

"While we have already taken significant steps to improve our remuneration structures, we know there is real concern in the community about the sales culture within banks and I'm confident these meaningful reforms will provide better outcomes for all customers," Ohlsson said.

Sedgewick urged all banks to "quickly implement these proposals" irrespective of what competitors adopt, and have until 2020 to do so.

Read more: NABANZSedgewickAndrew HaggerAssociationAustralia Fred OhlssonAustralian BankersAustralian Public Service Commissioner Stephen SedgwickNational Australia BankSedgwick Review
Editor's Choice
ALEX BURKE
AMP Capital has appointed a new head of its institutional and corporate business.
ALEX BURKE
AustralianSuper appointed a new chair for its investment committee.
ALEX DUNNIN
A Rainmaker study of extra benefits and features being offered by super funds in Australia reveals that technology and communication-oriented features are the most active area of product development.
ALEX BURKE
An $81 billion international investment manager took the majority stake in a large Australian provider of specialist medical software.
Videos
Brought to you by
19 APR 2017
There are two main avenues for investors to think about when approaching the use of alternative beta in an investment portfolio. The first is to adopt a core/satellite approach to constructing an alternatives ...
Get it Daily
Keep up to date, don't be the last to know! Get the Financial Standard Daily Newsletter.
SUBSCRIBE
Products
Pocket investment guides featuring adviser case studies and a glossary.
Investing trends and strategies from the industry’s thought leaders.
Putting the spotlight on investment products that matter.
Expert Feed
Andy Marshall
FS ADVICE
Rethinking client engagement
Financial advisers who take the time to understand their clients' personality, emotional intelligence and learning styles stand a better ...
Stephen Fay
FS SUPER
Landscape changes with potential for super implosion
Changes to default superannuation outlined by the recent Productivity Commission report have potential to fundamentally alter the landscape ...
Christopher Page
FS PRIVATE WEALTH
Redefining the family office
While the family office model has traditionally been the preserve of the ultra-rich, this may be changing very soon. Last week, Findex ...
Michelle Baltazar
FS MANAGED ACCOUNTS
Hitting the mark
Ten years from now, every financial adviser in the country will be offering their client a managed account solution. It may happen ...
Featured Profile
Professional Subscription for $295
(inc GST) for 1 year.
SUBSCRIBE
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
FS Advice
The Australian Journal of Financial Planning.
Get the free iPad app
Download the Financial Standard iPad app for FREE.
DOWNLOAD
Link to something 4EQsYEoz