One of the US' biggest pension funds, the $223 billion CalPERS, has filed a lawsuit against three of the world's most powerful rating agencies to claw back some of its losses from the GFC, but local super funds look unlikely to follow suit.
CalPERS had filed a suit in a California state court in relation to $1 billion in losses that it claimed were a result of inaccurate credit ratings from Moody's, Fitch Ratings and Standard & Poor's, according to a report by Reuters.
CalPERS said the "top" ratings on highly structured investment vehicles and complex packages of securities including subprime mortgages did not properly reflect the risk of these investments.
The suit said the AAA ratings given by the agencies "proved to be wildly inaccurate and unreasonably high", according to Reuters.
Despite CalPERS setting the precedent for other pension funds on taking rating agencies to court, local superannuation funds seem unlikely to follow suit.
For instance Greg Sword, chief executive of the $2 billion Labour Union Co-operative Retirement Fund, said the situation of pension funds in the US are different to those in Australia, because they relied on these agencies to provide ratings on instruments such as collateralised debt obligations and sub-prime mortgages - which in this case have proven to be flawed.
"I think the main concern with CalPERS and others would be the ratings that the agencies give to [products like] CDOs," said Sword.
"In our case, we weren't caught in that sort of programs, and I doubt that any of the Australian companies were caught [up] in those circumstances. You have to be a victim before you can claim.
"It doesn't affect us as we're not involved in any of that, but we understand that they [CalPERS] might be reasonably upset and they've relied upon the judgment of rating agencies," he said.
CalPERS reportedly bought $1.6 billion worth of structured investment vehicles in 2006, before they collapsed in 2007 and 2008.
The fund is seeking damages but did not specify the amount, Reuters noted.
Strength doesn't just come from numbers, it also comes from diversification.
That's the story behind the success of BlackRock's multi-asset income fund, which has delivered a high 7.4% annualised yield ... Watch video
Saul Eslake worked as an economist in the Australian financial markets for more than 25 years, including as Chief Economist at McIntosh Securities (a stockbroking firm) in the late 1980s, Chief Economist ... Watch video
We invite you to watch our latest video featuring Reece Birtles, chief investment officer of Legg Mason affiliate Martin Currie Australia.
Amid volatile markets, treacherously low term deposit rates and ... Watch video
You are invited to the Advisers Big Day Out (ABDO) Investment Manager Roadshow for 2016, where the country's leading fund managers will come to Victoria and Tasmania in May and share their knowledge ... Watch video
Financial Standard editor Mark Smith presents a roundup of the week's biggest industry news, and executive appointments. In this week's news:
User-pays model for ASIC
Following industry speculation ... Watch video
Get it Daily
FREE to your inbox, get the Financial Standard Daily Email.