APRA has entered the argument over fund scale, releasing research that finds larger funds outperform smaller ones.
The study analysed 280 super funds, covering not-for-profit and retail fund segments.
"Fund size has a positive impact on the performance of not- for-profit superannuation funds, which is evident both in gross returns and in expenses," noted the study's author, Dr James Richard Cummings.
But while no scale relationship was confirmed among retail funds, the APRA study reinforced concerns that in that sector the scale effects are dysfunctional.
"To the contrary, larger retail funds exhibit higher investment expense ratios, although not to a statistically significant level," wrote Dr Cummings.
Explaining the results for not-for-profit funds, Dr Cummings wrote that asset allocation and fees were the main factors.
"Larger not-for-profit funds have higher allocations to investments, such as private equity and real estate, where they are likely to have a size-related advantage. Lower investment expense ratios of larger not-for-profit funds suggest that they negotiate more favorable fee schedules with external managers. Larger funds (whether retail or not-for-profit) realise substantial operational cost savings," he noted.
The lack of a scale relationship being evident for retail funds suggests a combination of factors, such as these funds not passing on scale cost benefits in lower fees because they operate on a margin basis, though it may also reflect limitations in the APRA 'whole of fund' performance data.
Retail super funds reporting to APRA as high level legal entities containing large numbers of platform products may also complicate the retail analysis.
"Larger funds, both in the retail and not-for-profit sectors, had significantly lower operational expense ratios. This finding suggests that larger funds were able to spread fixed costs associated with administration and IT infrastructure over a larger asset base," wrote Dr Cummings.
The policy implications are that "fund members are likely to benefit from further industry consolidation in the not-for-profit sector," he concluded.
Bob believes plunging oil prices may extend the stockmarket rally by a year or two and discusses why investors could expect a volatile few months. Overall, he believes we are entering an era of low returns ... Watch video
Is the European economy dead in the water? Is faith on Abenomics waning? Why should investors be more optimistic about the US economy this year? Chris Probyn, the Boston-based chief economist of State ... Watch video
First, a confession. Mark may have started his career as an economist but he joins this year's panel not as a chief economist but as the head AXA Framlington Asia. This is to the benefit of the audience ... Watch video
James provides a local perspective and explains to the audience why the mining investment boom is an aberration and it is now a 'return to the old normal'. To view James Bond's slides please click ... Watch video
The anchor man of the panel, Saul provides great insights on the domestic economy. And bravely makes the forecast that the Reserve Bank will not cut interest rates this year and that the next move is up ... Watch video
Get it Daily
FREE to your inbox, get the Financial Standard Daily Email.