FPA expels and fines dishonest member

The Financial Planning Association Conduct Review Commission Disciplinary Panel has expelled financial adviser Darren Tindall and issued a fine of $16,000.

In a determination handed down on 10 February, the CRC decided to expel Tindall of PWM Advice, Orange, NSW, from the membership of the FPA for multiple breaches of the Code of Professional Practice.

The CRC found that Tindall failed to conduct himself professionally or ethically, acted with a lack of honesty, and engaged in acts of a misleading, deceptive, dishonest and fraudulent nature.

In his submissions, Tindall argued that a lesser fine should be applied as he gained no financial benefit by his actions, and that a heavy penalty would cause significant financial harm, but the CRC dismissed his claims, stating that expulsion was necessary for the protection of the profession, and the protection of the public.

"The public need to be able to trust the professionalism and ethics of the FPA's members," the panel stated.

"Given Mr Tindall's denials, the panel has no confidence any lesser sanction could be imposed that would meet the purpose of protection of the public."

Tindall is to pay a fine of $16,000, and must pay the costs and expenses of the FPA relating to the FPA's investigating and the disciplinary proceedings in the amount of $12,423.39.

Tindall first came to the attention of the FPA in 2014 after the association received a complaint relating to his conduct with a client in late 2013.

The complaint alleged that Tindall breached four sections of the FPA code including the giving of advice in relation to:

  • an online insurance application that was submitted for a client that falsely failed to disclose medical conditions;
  • a recommendation in a Statement of Advice that the client transfer her insurance, without disclosure of medical history; and
  • sending an email that improperly disclosed client information
In January 2017, the CRC found that Tindall breached all four allegations alleged and postponed announcing whether sanctions would be applied.

In the same month, corporate regulator ASIC also banned Tindall from providing financial services for a period five years.

Tindall has appealed the ban to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and has sought a stay of ASIC's decision, restricting the regulator from publishing their finding.The AAT heard the stay application on 27 January and on 9 February refused the stay, but has yet to set a date for the review of ASIC's banning decision.

The Association of Financial Advisers, of which Tindall is still a member, told Financial Standard it had only become aware of Tindall's indiscretions via media reports and had not received any similar complaints but is exploring the issue.

In a statement, AFA chief executive Brad Fox said the association's disciplinary procedures are built on fairness and will be used to assess the issues related to Tindall, with its key concern being the collection of facts.

Tindall has 21 days appeal the sanction to an alternative panel of the CRC.

Read more: ASICDarren TindallFinancial Planning Association Conduct Review Commission Disciplinary PanelAdministrative Appeals TribunalAssociation of Financial AdvisersBrad FoxCode of Professional PracticeFinancial StandardFPA forMr TindallNSWOrangeTindall of PWM Advice
Editor's Choice
DARREN SNYDER
The Bernie Fraser review of industry superannuation fund governance puts the onus of proof back on the government to demonstrate that one-third independent boards are the best way forward.
ALEX BURKE
Russell Investments will sell its actuarial consulting business to a leading global advisory firm.
EMMA RAPAPORT
The Financial Planning Association Conduct Review Commission Disciplinary Panel has expelled financial adviser Darren Tindall and issued a fine of $16,000.
EMMA RAPAPORT
The financial services sector should not be tempted by "shiny new [fintech] toys", and must continue to invest in maintenance of their core technology, says APRA chairman Wayne Byres.
Videos
Brought to you by
2 NOV 2016
Our latest video features Franklin Templeton director of Australian fixed income, Andrew Canobi. He explains the unique investment strategy behind the Franklin Australian Absolute Return Bond Fund. The ...
Get it Daily
Keep up to date, don't be the last to know! Get the Financial Standard Daily Newsletter.
SUBSCRIBE
Products
Pocket investment guides featuring adviser case studies and a glossary.
Investing trends and strategies from the industry’s thought leaders.
Putting the spotlight on investment products that matter.
Expert Feed
Alex Dunnin
FS ADVICE
Taking the risk out of insurance reform
Dysfunctional arguments Americans have regarding their Affordable Care Act remind us how poorly most people understand insurance. Following ...
Stephen Fay
FS SUPER
Reality and perception of super returns
What matters more, the investment return on your superannuation balance or the how you feel about your return? Which does a member ...
Christopher Page
FS PRIVATE WEALTH
Redefining the family office
While the family office model has traditionally been the preserve of the ultra-rich, this may be changing very soon. Last week, Findex ...
Michelle Baltazar
FS MANAGED ACCOUNTS
When the disruptors are getting disrupted
2017 is going to be another year for the disruptors, including managed accounts providers - but their challengers, too, are not too ...
Featured Profile
Professional Subscription for $295
(inc GST) for 1 year.
SUBSCRIBE
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
FS Advice
The Australian Journal of Financial Planning.
Get the free iPad app
Download the Financial Standard iPad app for FREE.
DOWNLOAD
Link to something eNBfBMsh